Edinburgh

The Witchery

Name: The Witchery
Address: 352 Castlehill, Edinburgh, EH1 2NF, United Kingdom

StayScore

/100

Confidence: High

352 Castlehill, Edinburgh, EH1 2NF, United Kingdom

View on Google Maps →

★★★★★5-star hotel

Hidden in a collection of historic buildings at the gates to Edinburgh Castle, James Thomson's Witchery is the most spectacularly atmospheric destination in the city. The stunning decor and legendary food have ensured the Witchery has become a much loved Edinburgh institution.

Score breakdown

Transparent reputation signals

StayScore

91/100

9.6/10

4.3/5

4.5/5

Scores last verified: 30 Jul 2026

StayScore Analysis

Why this hotel scores 91/100

The Witchery is best suited to travellers who want an unforgettable, theatrical Edinburgh stay steeped in history and atmosphere. Tucked into the historic buildings at the gates of Edinburgh Castle, it appeals most to couples and food lovers seeking dramatic decoration, atmospheric candlelit evenings and a strong sense of place rather than a neutral, modern base. The hotel works well as a special-occasion retreat and as a memorable centrepiece for exploring the Royal Mile and Old Town’s historic sights.

Amenities

What this hotel offers

Free WiFiNon-smoking roomsRestaurant24-hour front deskTerraceHeatingTea/coffee maker in all roomsBreakfast

Highlights

✓ Unmissable, dramatic setting at the gates of Edinburgh Castle
✓ Renowned, legendary dining and spectacular period decor
✓ Ideal for romantic and special-occasion stays in Edinburgh’s Old Town

Things to know

• Highly theatrical, historic character suits romance and atmosphere more than minimalist, contemporary tastes
• Intimate layout and Old Town location work better for couples or small parties than large family groups

Hotel surroundings